They had a sign outside touting their "Almighty Brisket" sandwich, so I stepped in to take a look. The sandwiches here were a bit steep at $10 a pop. Throw in a hose made soda and chips and it jumps to $14.
So here's their brisket sandwich, served with cheddar, caramelized onions, and horseradish mayo on a toasted brioche bun. The brisket was damn good and just melted in your mouth! Probably the best brisket sandwich I've had, even when compared to the ones you get a BBQ joints.
I also took the plunge and also tried out their homemade celery soda. It was pretty awesome and infused with refreshing herbs that gave it a slightly bitter bite.
Although the sandwich was great, I still prefer This Little Piggy. It's just a few doors down and for the same price you get a roast beef sandwich smothered with cheese and gravy that's fit enough for two! Joe Dough is still worth a try though. Here's the rest of their menu...
135 First Ave
(between St Marks Pl & 9th St)