I practically waited until the last day when the deal is about to expire to head over, with numerous people stopping by to claim theirs the last minute as well.
Butter Lane's cupcakes are great, if a tad sweet. There are three cake basis, vanilla, chocolate, and banana (which ended up being my favorite).
Here's two of the flavors...the excellent sea salt with a caramel syrup, and I believe French Vanilla.
The rest of the cupcakes were: Another sea salt/caramel, cocunut, maple pecan, and cappucino. All of the flavors were really good, though I would suggest passing on the vanilla base/cake and getting chocolate or banana instead...
Saw this sign outside the shop....never thought about it but it's true!!
(between 1st Ave & Avenue A)
Neighborhood: East Village